{
  "review_date": "2026-10-30",
  "primary_sources": {
    "pull_request": "https://github.com/omacom/omarchy/pull/13968",
    "github_api": "https://api.github.com/repos/omacom/omarchy/pulls/13968",
    "proof_report": "https://portal.reqproof.com/projects/omarchy/changes/pr/13968",
    "latest_repository_comment": "https://github.com/omacom/omarchy/pull/13968#issuecomment-6047465224",
    "video": "https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/d0f17224-a5f0-4e0f-b820-c82ce77f1d08",
    "license": "https://github.com/omacom/omarchy/blob/2514ad72fa9203cfe7acd5f0f8fd4b8d92ada806/LICENSE"
  },
  "source_revisions": {
    "pr_head": "2514ad72fa9203cfe7acd5f0f8fd4b8d92ada806",
    "current_github_base": "c05d90196fc0dd5c21e2e797d80ffcc60d5e39fa",
    "original_reproduction_base": "8b4eae6",
    "video_head": "b2dae8db74d7bbe3710383563a325171cfbb80f0",
    "proof_evaluation_upstream_base": "035ce29f03bdd97a09af80ef5f2d22d7a98930d6",
    "proof_evaluation_base": "1e43373287afbd6dca4674ad463d5b5db7812358",
    "proof_evaluated_merge": "e491b5245b5d5f07f9062f81703ba76f6ab7ccce",
    "proof_current_baseline_abbreviated": "156d3b91",
    "proof_evidence_package": "epkg-cf996aa899db700d624cb0ab8fce3d39a8df3fd69dda26d711f4eba56e97be52",
    "comparison_pr_13681_head": "6acbace10861cc0e172ec754b7ed80cd7bf8bc93"
  },
  "current_state": {
    "github_state": "open",
    "merged": false,
    "mergeable": false,
    "mergeable_state": "dirty",
    "proof_state": "Re-check pending",
    "maintainer_approval_recorded": false,
    "auditor_recommendation": "Recommend acceptance; stale; author and auditor are both buger"
  },
  "upstream_changes": {
    "files": [
      "docs/menu.md",
      "shell/plugins/menu/MenuModel.js",
      "test/shell.d/menu-test.sh"
    ],
    "additions": 98,
    "deletions": 9,
    "production_functions": [
      "stripJsonc",
      "parseMenuJsonc"
    ]
  },
  "independently_reproduced": {
    "environment": "Linux, Node v24.22.1 (PR author used Node 26)",
    "original_upstream_suite": {
      "command": "bash repro-base/test/shell.d/menu-test.sh",
      "passed_assertions": 127,
      "exit_code": 0
    },
    "head_upstream_suite": {
      "command": "bash repro-head/test/shell.d/menu-test.sh",
      "passed_assertions": 163,
      "exit_code": 0
    },
    "new_assertions": {
      "command": "node assertion-check.cjs",
      "cases": 36,
      "basePass": 20,
      "baseFail": 16,
      "headPass": 36,
      "headFail": 0
    },
    "original_fixture": {
      "base_rows": 344,
      "head_rows": 344,
      "serialized_row_data_identical": true
    },
    "later_audit_fixture": {
      "fixture_revision": "035ce29f03bdd97a09af80ef5f2d22d7a98930d6",
      "base_rows": 346,
      "head_rows": 346,
      "serialized_row_data_identical": true,
      "extra_rows": [
        "install.service.microsoft",
        "remove.service.microsoft"
      ],
      "baseline_parser_identical_to_original": true
    },
    "published_comparison": {
      "command": "cd repro-head && node compare.js ../other-model.js",
      "iterations": 200000,
      "differing_iterations": 4187,
      "differing_with_comment_skip_disabled": 0,
      "unique_input_strings": 855,
      "both_reject_iterations": 62183,
      "other_parser_reject_iterations": 66370,
      "head_parser_reject_iterations": 62183,
      "uniqueness_method": "Added a Set of generated input strings to the unmodified deterministic generation sequence; compare-audit.js"
    }
  },
  "report_observed_not_rerun": {
    "requirements_in_scope": 30,
    "requirements_changed_by_audit": 7,
    "modified_requirements": 3,
    "added_requirements": 4,
    "requirement_text_changed": 5,
    "metadata_only": 2,
    "other_requirements_to_preserve": 23,
    "obligation_checks": {
      "total": 62,
      "observed_passing": 35,
      "covered_by_child_spec": 19,
      "accepted_known_debt": 4,
      "not_applicable": 4
    },
    "tests": {
      "passed": 69,
      "failed": 0,
      "skipped": 0,
      "tagged_tests_joined": "5/5"
    },
    "code_reach": {
      "changed_decision_lines_reached": "17/17",
      "decisions_fully_exercised": "34/34"
    },
    "audit_checks_skipped": 13,
    "behavior_findings": {
      "total": 136,
      "awaiting_maintainers": 135,
      "fixed": 1,
      "group_sizes": [
        124,
        4,
        3,
        2,
        2
      ],
      "comparison_inputs": 213,
      "partitions": 5
    }
  },
  "formalized_requirements": [
    {
      "id": "SW-REQ-260927-66FW",
      "formula": "trailing_comma_dropped <=> (!comma_in_string & next_char_closes_json)",
      "domain": "At a comma; next character means first character after skipping whitespace and // comments through their line breaks.",
      "status": "proposed audit-layer clause, not maintainer-approved"
    },
    {
      "id": "SW-REQ-260928-C8W1",
      "formula": "comment_tail_dropped <=> !comment_in_string",
      "domain": "At a // opener; preserve the line feed to avoid joining adjacent tokens.",
      "status": "proposed audit-layer clause, not maintainer-approved"
    },
    {
      "id": "SW-REQ-260928-BMFE",
      "formula": "when array_root_present the menu_model shall always satisfy array_root_rejected",
      "status": "proposed audit-layer clause, not maintainer-approved"
    },
    {
      "id": "SW-REQ-261001-BNZG",
      "formula": "when space_outside_string the menu_model shall always satisfy space_passed_as_ascii",
      "domain": "All JS \\s outside strings: keep LF; emit each other matched character as one ASCII space.",
      "status": "proposed audit-layer clause, not maintainer-approved"
    }
  ],
  "report_anchors": [
    "accepting",
    "accepting-compare",
    "behaviour-changes",
    "impact",
    "evidence",
    "removed-behaviour",
    "unresolved",
    "decision",
    "decision-authority",
    "history"
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Evidence is historical and current report says re-check pending. Current GitHub base differs and mergeability is dirty.",
    "69 recorded Proof tests were inspected, not rerun here. The independent local replay is upstream Node shell tests and comparison harness, not Quickshell UI validation.",
    "200000 generated comparisons are not 200000 unique test cases; this deterministic run has 855 distinct inputs and includes invalid inputs.",
    "17/17 reached lines do not establish behavioral correctness or certification; 34/34 decision count is reported, not independently instrumented in this audit.",
    "62 obligations includes child coverage, accepted debt and not-applicable checks; only 35 are observed passing.",
    "Zero skipped tests is a test-report count, while 13 separate audit checks were skipped.",
    "30 requirements is mapped scope, not proof of no impact elsewhere; whole-file traces are coarse and call effects are unavailable for this package.",
    "QV4 engine behavior/performance parity and newly valid user files overriding shipped rows remain unanswered review questions.",
    "Six relevant tests lack a recorded confirmation they execute the changed code; producer signature is not attested.",
    "135 intended behavior changes are auditor classifications, not approvals or bug counts.",
    "A formula makes intended behavior reviewable; it is not itself evidence of mathematical verification.",
    "20\u201330 minutes is a product design target proposed by the user, not a measured approval time established by this PR.",
    "MIT license covers repository software/documentation; attribute source and retain license notice for substantial reused portions. It does not independently license every external media asset."
  ]
}
